A federal judge has called the city of Nashville's actions "fishy" and is now sending an alleged price-fixing case to a jury trial.
It is small business vs. big city government and free enterprise vs. government regulation all playing out on the streets of Middle Tennessee.
At issue is whether the government can tell a small, private business how much to charge its customers.
This all began when Ali Bokhari had an idea to charge taxi cab prices but deliver passengers in black Lincoln Towncars. By doing so, he could undercut the big limo services while cutting into the bargain taxi prices.
By 2010, he had 30 cars charging $25 for airport rides.
However, Metro then stepped in and set a minimum rate of $45 for all car service from the airport.
That changed everything, and Bokhari's company, Metro Livery, is now down 15 cars.
"We are struggling, but we are optimistic," he said.
The Institute for Justice in Washington, DC, then sued on behalf of Metro Livery and other discount car services, accusing the city of Nashville of unconstitutional price fixing.
Metro Nashville says it's just trying to protect its customers and ensure safe, reliable service.
"Because of problems with illegal taxi services, we want to make sure we differentiate the services between taxi cabs and livery services. We can use one or two measures - one is strict prearrangement, and another is minimum rate," said Brian McQuistion, with the Metro Transportation Licensing Commission.
Federal Judge Kevin Sharp refused Metro's request to throw out the lawsuit. In fact, Sharp appears to be leaning toward the other way.
The judge called Metro's alleged price fixing "fishy" and said it will be for the jury to determine whether enactment of the ordinance passes the "smell test."
The case goes to trial in three weeks. If victorious, Metro Livery will return to its $25 airport rate.
The Institute for Justice said it took this case because it believes Metro government was using its power to protect groups from competition.
Copyright WSMV 2013 (Meredith Corporation). All rights reserved.
Saturday, May 25 2013 3:27 PM EDT2013-05-25 19:27:56 GMT
Deputies with the Sumner Co. Sheriff's office have shut down Highway 109 near Portland after a collision between a semi-truck and another vehicle. The wreck happened just after 8 a.m. Officials tellMore >>
Sumner County Sheriff Sonny Weatherford said that Stephanie Law, 43, lost control of her silver Chevy Impala as she traveled north on Highway 109.More >>
Saturday, May 25 2013 10:45 AM EDT2013-05-25 14:45:56 GMT
A driver might face charges after a violent wreck on I-65 Friday night. A car ran into a bridge pillar at the Rosa Parks Boulevard exit around 11:30 p.m., according to police. A woman was rushed to theMore >>
Metro police arrested a driver after a violent wreck on I-65 Friday night.More >>
Dan Sligh and his wife were in their pickup truck on Interstate 5 heading to a camping trip when a bridge before them disappeared in a "big puff of dust."More >>
The trucker was hauling drilling equipment when his load bumped against the steel framework over an Interstate 5 bridge. He looked in his rearview mirror and watched in horror as the span collapsed into the water behind him....More >>
Friday, May 24 2013 7:48 PM EDT2013-05-24 23:48:47 GMT
One person was killed in a car wreck on I-24 this morning in Rutherford County. The wreck occurred near mile marker 86 in the eastbound lanes, which is partially blocked according to the Tennessee DepartmentMore >>
One person was killed in a car wreck on I-24 this morning in Rutherford County.More >>
Friday, May 24 2013 10:48 PM EDT2013-05-25 02:48:33 GMT
Metro police are investigating a theft and assault at a south Nashville smoke shop. Investigators say two men showed up at the Smoke Token Smoke Shop on Harding Place to complain about a glass pipe theyMore >>
Metro police are investigating a theft and assault at a south Nashville smoke shop.More >>
Friday, May 24 2013 7:07 PM EDT2013-05-24 23:07:39 GMT
A man accused of striking and killing two pedestrians while driving drunk near Music Row in December 2011 has pleaded guilty to reduced charges. The plea has the parents of one of the victims saying theMore >>
A man accused of striking and killing two pedestrians while driving drunk near Music Row in December 2011 has pleaded guilty to reduced charges.More >>
Friday, May 24 2013 6:39 PM EDT2013-05-24 22:39:20 GMT
David Michael Matson
A National Weather Service employee who police said beat a puppy to death and killed another five or six dogs pleaded not guilty Friday to aggravated animal cruelty.Police said last November that DavidMore >>
A man who police said beat a puppy to death and killed another five or six animals pleaded not guilty Friday to aggravated animal cruelty.More >>