The outcome of a U.S. Supreme Court decision could have a big impact on pawn shops or anyone reselling anything online or at garage sales.
The case at issue is Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons and centers around the first-sale doctrine in copyright law that says once a person buys a copyrighted item, the copyrights have been eliminated.
The Supreme Court will decide if the first-sale doctrine will apply to products made outside the United States.
Many people who are short on cash turn to pawnshops to sell something they no longer want to keep. People can do that thanks to the first-sale doctrine.
The doctrine allows anyone to buy and then sell things on Craigslist, eBay or a pawn shop without getting permission from the copyright holder of the items.
University of Missouri-Kansas City law professor Christopher Holman says if the court sides with the challengers in the case, it could drive manufacturing businesses outside the United States.
Brian Anderson, owner of the Olathe Trading Post and Pawn, says the change would not be good for business.
"About 50 to 70 percent of the items in our store and across America could no longer be sold by the owners who had purchased them legally," Anderson said.
However, Holman doesn't feel it will have that sort of an impact.
"You don't see people going after someone for reselling a book. In every case it's been more of a commercial operation," Holman said.
Holman said not applying the first-sale doctrine abroad could have a different impact.
"The negative impact for the United States is now you have an incentive to have copyrighted objects manufactured outside the United States because they will receive preferential treatment," Holman said.
Pawnshop owners, like Anderson, say they hope the ruling doesn't change what they can sell, no matter where a product was made.
"It has always been our right to sell our items," Anderson said.
The case began with an attempt to crack down on gray markets. Court documents allege that a college student from Thailand went to school at Cornell University in New York and had his relatives buy cheap books in Thailand and ship them to him. He then started an online business, selling the books for $1.2 million, according to court documents.
The Supreme Court is expected to hear the case at the end of the month.
A similar case against Costco ended with a 4-4 split decision because one justice stepped down from the case.
Copyright 2012 KCTV (Meredith Corp.) All rights reserved.
Monday, May 20 2013 8:21 AM EDT2013-05-20 12:21:38 GMT
The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation has issued an AMBER Alert for a Murfreesboro boy who was taken during a violent domestic dispute Sunday. Authorities believe 8 year-old Gabriel Swaney is with hisMore >>
A Murfreesboro boy is safe after an Amber Alert was issued overnight.More >>
Monday, May 20 2013 9:35 AM EDT2013-05-20 13:35:57 GMT
Police are searching for two young men who robbed and carjacked two people at the scene of a crash in Antioch early Monday morning. A minor crash happened at 294 Chimney Drive at about 12:30 am. PoliceMore >>
Police are searching for two young men who robbed and carjacked two people at the scene of a crash in Antioch early Monday morning.More >>
Monday, May 20 2013 7:26 AM EDT2013-05-20 11:26:34 GMT
A Smyrna man is in the hospital after being shot at a basketball court Sunday night. Police said a fight broke out on Mason Tucker Drive around 8:30 p.m. As the victim was driving away from the court,More >>
A Smyrna man is in the hospital after being shot at a basketball court Sunday night.More >>
Monday, May 20 2013 12:18 PM EDT2013-05-20 16:18:47 GMT
Courtesy: Jeff from Portland
An overturned tractor-trailer has closed southbound lanes of Interstate 65 in Robertson County on Monday morning. The wreck occurred around 6 a.m. near mile marker 111 near Cross Plains, TN, said theMore >>
One lane of Interstate 65 is now open in Robertson County after an overturned tractor-trailer crash Monday morning.More >>
Sunday, May 19 2013 11:48 PM EDT2013-05-20 03:48:50 GMT
Two Columbia police cruisers collided Sunday morning while trying to stop a suspected drunk driver. Investigators say an alert citizen spotted a vehicle driving erratically and called police. The car wasMore >>
Two Columbia police cruisers collided Sunday morning while trying to stop a suspected drunk driver.More >>
Monday, May 20 2013 8:40 AM EDT2013-05-20 12:40:31 GMT
There is a slight risk of severe thunderstorms for northwest Middle Tennessee Tuesday night into Wednesday morning. The biggest threat will be west of a line from Waynesboro to Springfield, TN. An upperMore >>
There is a slight risk of severe thunderstorms for northwest Middle Tennessee Tuesday night into Wednesday morning.More >>